Ya I agree with you. But I think if Theo thought he was getting a deal, he would consider it. Alot of non baesball issues might play this thing out. Lets do a couple " what ifs"(normally I try to stick clear of such things, but given the current lack of news, I'll make a change).
SD to give a "deal" or "discount" would have to be desperate. Stemming from the economy, SD's owner's divorce, somthing of this nature.
Knowing this, in times of crisis(I use crisis, knowing full well this isn't a life or death dilehma) Most people go with what they know. And Theo and Towers know each other well. There wouldn't need to be the normal 2 step GM's normally play with each other when discussing a possible trade. No, they could get right down to buisness.
Towers should roughly know what he can get from Theo. I don't think he will ask for the Moon. And considering what he has been getting offered, if he is selective and not too greedy, he could come away with a nice deal for his ball club.
I also think Farrell would have to help him change his game a bit. Use his off speed stuff better. Beckett did it in 2007, last year he got a little FB happy at times. After the Post Season he had just come off who could blame him LOL But it showed you have be able to change it up. Power pitching is alot more useful in 40-50 degree weather, when your hands shatter when the bat hits the ball. Then it is when it's 90 and sunny.
I honestly think Bowden could be the center piece of a deal. Nothing close to him has been offered otherwise. I'm sure he will start a Buchholz, but remember, this is all beginning with Theo thinking he is getting a deal. And if Buchholz is asked for I don't believe Theo will consider it a deal(unless its just Buchholz+1, but that's another post).
Bowden+2 would seem to me as Towers believeing he is getting enough back, while Theo believe's it to be a "deal" so to speak, or discount.
What does everyone else think would be a good offer?
I still believe Bowden/Alamanzar+OF prospects is a solid start, while not comprimising the future of the team as well.
Beckett
Dicke-K
Lester
Wake(I only put Wake here to break up the hard throwing styles of Peavy and Lester)
Peavy
That's a solid rotation with 4/5 under 30 years of age.
This also leaves Buchholz to be groomed more in AAA.
$ aside, because no pitcher is worth the kind of money some get payed. Peavy is alot better option as the teams #4 or #5 SP. If he give 6IP with 4-4.75 ERA, I'll take that and run with it.