Ok, I have an interesting idea. Just hear me out. It will fix the hole "running out of players in extra innings" thing, as well as the "deserving players missing out b/c all the teams had to be represented" thing and the "players not getting to play b/c the manager is saving them in case there's extra innings" thing. We do the voting just like we do it now, except without the "every team" limitation. Whoever the most deserving players are get in. Then, the manager chooses 6 players (3 pitchers, 3 position players; this part can change), who can only play in extra innings. If there's team's that didn't get any players named to the original roster, he has to choose a player from those teams (so everyone is getting represented). And he won't be worried about saving players for extra innings. Thoughts?