What have the GM's of the Yankees, Tampa, Texas, Detroit and Los Angeles added, because all that matters is what he did to keep pace with the competition. These numbers mean nothing in a vacuum. If you insist on playing War, so far Papelbon has accounted for 0.7, Reddick 2.5, and Lowrie 2.1. That's a total of 5.3. Add to that the 1.1. that Bard gave us last season a reliever and the - 0.3 that he has produced as a starter and we're at 6.6 WAR lost. Then there is the 2.6 War that Aceves had in his swingman role last year and he is currently at -0.3 as a closer. Total WAR lost by Cherries is 9.5 War gained according to your post 7.0. He's down 2.5 WAR. As I said, he hasn't achieved anything yet, as born out by the way the team has been playing.
It looks like your opinion has been refuted.:harhar: