If the AL was never planning on giving a DH the award, then they shouldn't have created the position. If pitchers, who play less than DHs, win the MVP, why can;t a DH? In the MVP award history, a pitcher has won 17/146 times, a 11% clip if u do the math, Eckersley won in '92, and hes the last pitcher to win. Even if a pitcher doesn't win that much, if Ortiz played 1st base and played average defense, he would win, it obviously wasn't an issue when Miguel Tejada issued 21 errors in 2002, Frank Thomas' 15 errors in 1993, Barry Bonds .968 FP in 2002, or Ken Caminiti's 20 errors and low FP of .954 in 1996.
BTW, when Papi played 70 games at 1b in 1998, he only made 6 errors w/ a .989 FP. Since then, he's never gotten the chance to play the position. Why? Becuase former Yankee Ron Coomer took over that job and went to the All-star game that year. Taking over that position into 2000 and then handing the job off to Doug Mientkiewicz
I sorta quoted myself here from the other thread.