Im sorry, you just have to watch Manny every game to understand how good of a hitter he really is... Andruw Jones hits 260. While Manny hits 320. Manny has more RBIs and the homers are about the same... Andruw is younger but he strikes out like crazy and he is a FA after next season so there is no guarente that he will be back for 2008.
2006 OBP SLG AVG OPS
Manny- .439 .619 .321 1.058
Jones- 363 .531 .262 .894
Career
Manny 411 .600 .314 1.011
Jones 345 .505 .267 850
The Numbers dont really compare Manny is a better hitter and his Defense is fine at Fenway park, and really not that bad anywhere eles.