It is obvious that the guy is human. He has looked shaky lately, but he will definatly bounce back. He did not give up a hit to Baltimore on the 13th, even though he let two runners score (not to the help of Alex Cora). But would you consider moving him into the rotation next year? We are obviously thin up there. Beckett and Lester should improve, but lately those guys seem like a mixed bag.
Heres the big question. Will this weaken the bullpen too much? I've thought about this a lot and I say it will. We have seen that it is very rare to go out and get middle relief and even closer talent in the free agent market and find that they will be successful. IE. The latin double uglies, alan embree, bob howry, foulke (even tho he was terrific one year). The one exception has been Timlin. Seems there is a 25% chance that a reliever can flawlessly make a transition onto a new team and accept a new role.
That being said, Papelbon should stay in the closer role. Hansen hasn't shown he can consistantly pitch on the major league level. He's shown he can do it, even dominate, but he might be another year away from really solidifying any kind of weakness. If I'm not mistaken, Timlin is probably gone and there is now a huge void out there. I like how solid MDC has been for us, and he will probably take over as the main set up guy. The best approach I think we should take is to go out and sign a FA starting pitcher such as a Zito. Does anyone else know who will be avaiable in the market this winter? That would be the best way to help the team for next year... I think think Papelbon will be a good starter in the future and would contribute more solid innings (200 IP, as opposed to 75 IP).