Why??
Granted I won't turn him away if he comes here, but I don't want him that bad. I don't want that kind of commitment to him, both in terms of dollars and years. It's so unfortunate that this years pitching market is filled with a bunch of overrated, overvalued guys who are gonna cash in big because of lack of alternatives and good contract years. Same applies to CC, I'm sick of this bs with him, he's not even all that great. I think he's overrated, he sucks in the postseason, and with his body he'll probably start breaking down half way through his contract. Even Derek Lowe is gonna make big bucks and that's sickening. While I would certainly like to have CC, or even Burnett to a lesser extent, I won't be very disappointed at all if we miss out on all of them. I'd be content with just Andy and Sheets. I know exactly what will happen if we sign CC; he'll make $140+ mil, win 15-16 games in the regular season with a ERA of 3.50 or somewhere in that neighborhood, put together a representable season, and then when the postseason comes in his first start he'll be knocked out in the 4th inning after giving up 6 runs to a team like the White Sox or the Tigers or something. We sign Burnett, I see Pavano all over again. You realize the only year Burnett hasn't been on the DL was his contract year? He'll be hurt for an extended period of time in his 4th start.
Now hopefully if we end up getting either of them I turn out to be wrong, but I just have a bad feeling about these guys. Idk what it is, but I think a guy like Sheets can give us the same performance as a Burnett for a fraction of the cost. And if he gets injured, which he also very well may do, we don't have a billion dollars invested in him over 20 years. As much as it pains me to say it, maybe Gom's right, we should have just gotten Johan last year when we had the chance. He's the closest thing to automatic ace to hit the market in the last 5 years, this one included. If CC doesn't want our $140, fine let him go be a Dodger. If Atlanta or Boston wants to get in a bidding war with us over Burnett, let him go. We're better off saving our money. I dont want to beg these guys to come here just so they can get hurt or choke in October. We've seen it happen all too often over the last 6-8 years.