You're right, Gaston just didn't even occur to me considering how long he had been out of the dugout prior to comign back this season. I agree Manuel is underrated, but he did have some great Guardians teams.
Cox still led his team to 15 straight division titles. LaRussa is a very inteligent and innovative manager, I can't put him beneath Francona, sorry. As for Lou, that's debatable, could go either way. Lou has a much greater legacy, however and has accomplished a shitload. He might not have as many rings but he has undeniably had an incredible managerial career. Can't forget his 116 win 2001 Mariners. But like I said, debatable.
Fair enough. I wasn't claiming that that last group I mentioned were in fact better than Francona, just sayign they were guys who could make a case. I think the job Hurdle did last year though was incredible, and although his tenure in Colorado hasn't produced much succes he's done a great job managing those players, as well as being a very good in game manager.
Absolutely without a doubt. Not to take anything awayfrom Tito, but as a testament to Scoscia's abilities. He is probably, at least IMO the best manager in the AL.
He's a good baseball man and a great teacher. He might only have 3 years as a big-league manager (not including the 27 games he managed the Angels while a coach), but I like what I've seen from him. he's done a great job bringing the young players together the past few years, and then getting them over the top this year with an added veteran influence. I think he can potentially be great. Not to mention all those years he spent coaching in the Angels organization, 6 of which were under Scoscia. He may still have a lot to prove, but I think he's done an incredible job.