I'd like to see the people who voted A, and hear their reasoning behind it, but I'm guessing that was all just trolling anyway. This board sure has become a parody of itself lately.
I chose D+. The rotation needed to be strengthened and it was not. We went into last season with what was thought to be one of the best rotations in the game and it imploded. That was not foreseen of course but now that 2 of it's members have been replaced with a set up man and either Aceves or some guy picked out of a dump it's weaker than it was going into last year, and that isn't good at all. I think either this rotation will perform similar to last year, which isn't good, be worse, which obviously isn't good, or there is a small small chance it will be better. But that would be a huge surprise.
I'm fine with the bullpen pretty much, especially if it has Aceves in it.
Moving Scutaro didn't make sense, unless there is something I'm missing. For 2 years he was pretty consistent, and I'd rather have that than uncertainty at SS.
I'm not even entirely sure what the RF situation is, I'm guessing a platoon situation. Ross and Kalish when he is healthy, right? I'm ok with this and would of rather gotten a SP than a RF so I'm not really gonna complain.
The Ortiz situation was blown out of proportion, and I'm not too concerned about it.
I'd give him higher if he worked on the Rotation more but that can change during the season, hopefully when it's not too late. Also the Scutaro thing.