Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

notin

Old-Timey Member
  • Posts

    53,514
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    45

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking

Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

News

2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by notin

  1. MLB has rules for how many AB are required to qualify for a batting title. They have no such rules for how many innings one has to play in the field in order to qualify go out a Gold Glove…
  2. Jorge Mateo was better in every metric and got completely ignored…
  3. Well really all that matters is what Jerry DiPoto thinks. He’ll probably consider it more once he’s done negotiating that Tommy Milone / Blake Snell trade. No word on Enmanuel Valdez for Winker?
  4. High on Bassitt. Not so much on Rodon…
  5. Of course if Seattle plays hardball on Hosmer the Sox could always offer 2b Enmanuel Valdez (.918 OPS across 3 leages in 2022) for Winker…
  6. I can name another player not covered by Mariners’ fans and (more importantly) management - Jesse Winker. Let’s not pretend the Mariners only acquire players that make the collective nipples of the fans perk up; you guys did acquire Carlos Santana last year. And BTV values Hosmer more than they value Winker…
  7. I couldn’t think of anyone else for CF. My problem with Kiermaier is he gets hurt a lot and can’t hit against anyone but the Red Sox. But if the Sox sign Judge and Kiermaier, then trade Hosmer to Seattle for the disgruntled and unwelcome Jesse Winker for DH. (They’re issues with Winker include his lack of desire to work on his fielding. So if he’s a DH, who cares?) Hosmer has a full NTC, but so far we only know he doesn’t want to go to a rebuilding team. Seattle, as an ALDS participant, certainly is not one, and their starting 1b (Carlos Santana) is a free agent. Certainly Hosmer would prefer starting in Seattle over watching Casas in Boston. And while Hosmer isn’t exactly the most exciting player, Seattle might enjoy his minimum wage salary…
  8. Well they’ll be paying off Gerrit Cole for the same money while watching him pitch like Garrett Richards…
  9. Kike to SS as a stopgap? Then Kiermaier for CF and Judge in RF…
  10. Ok let’s say it comes down to that. Judge fills multiple needs for the Sox, as he does for any team. He could easily play RF at Fenway. He’s probably looking for, at minimum 10 years $320mill. Certainly the first few seasons should be worth it, even if he can’t replicate his 2022. But given his age (30) and injury history, how many years would he need to be close to his 2021 self to justify it? And how many years of unproductive Judge can any team expect at the end of the deal?
  11. Those 4 games are his reality. The other 158 games are the outlier…
  12. That does include Bogaerts and his $20mill…
  13. Why would the Sox spend $10mill to get Wil Myers and his .804 OPS vs LHP when Dalbec and his .855 OPS vs LHP are already on board at league minimum?
  14. I like that OF. But I doubt the Sox sign Nimmo if he gets a QO, as it would cost then two draft picks. In which case, who’s Plan B?
  15. Quintana over both. But if they just sign Bassitt, that’s a good start. The Sox probably (against my wishes) move Whitlock to the rotation with Pivetta, Sale and Bello. And Paxton might exercise his $4mil player option and get in his 30-40 IP, too…
  16. Am I supposed to be impressed that full time starter Mike Stanley accrued more fWAR than fourth OF Refsnyder? Also why are we comparing the two? Is 59yo Mike Stanley a candidate for a Sox bench role?
  17. If you like Kluber’s 5.0 fWAR since 2019, what about Jose Quintana and his 8.1 fWAR in that same timeframe? Also he’s 3 years younger, coming off a better season, and didn’t move to the Boston area and then still snub the Red Sox for the Yankees…
  18. The best thing Mike Stanley was get traded for Tony Armas Jr, who in turn became part of a much, much better trade…
  19. For $1.2mill, the Sox can bring back Refsnyder …
  20. But only one of them was soiled by pinstripes…
  21. I think Sale and Bello probably occupy one rotation spot. Someone has to be demoted for both games Sale pitches next year…
  22. So he’s a less versatile but more expensive Dalbec?
  23. He also said the 2018 Sox would not compete in the AL East. (I suppose one could argue that the 2018 Sox really did not find the ALE all that competitive.)
  24. Fulmer, Montero, Bogaerts, Wacha, Bassitt. I’m ok with Benintendi and Mancini. No on Myers. (Where is Myers playing in your proposal?) I do wonder if - against my wishes - the Sox don’t just use Hosmer and Dalbec in a DH platoon…
  25. How did he outmanage him in game 5? By remembering Gerrit Cole was on his roster?
×
×
  • Create New...