Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

notin

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    52,190

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    45

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking

Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

News

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by notin

  1. notin
    His 4.12 in 9 career starts does put him a lot closer to Mike Maddux than to Greg, but I’m not sure I’d call him “terrible.” If that’s terrible, then what adjective describes Gerrit Cole and his 4.60 ERA since the All Star break?
  2. notin
    Most ball players go where the money is. If the Sox meet his price, he’ll stay…
  3. notin
    Hugh did like Alcantara, which would be great. IMO right team, wrong pitcher. Alcantara is probably not available, since they just extended him to a VERY reasonable 5 yr $56mill extension. Pedro Lopez and Sixto Sanchez are probably more available…
  4. notin
    Did you pledge more?
  5. notin
    And extend Devers…
  6. notin
    I have my doubts “elite SP” is a realistic target. For one thing, I’m guessing it sounds like a rare commodity that’s difficult to acquire. For another, injuries or not, the Sox made some of those moves last off-season. I wouldn’t be surprised if the Sox cobbled together a rotation from Sale, Paxton, Pivetta, Wacha (hopefully), Whitlock, Crawford, and Bello while still having Winckowski, Mata, Ward, and a few others ready in the minors for depth. Focus more on the bullpen, hopefully 3 new arms. Headlined by Michael Fulmer. Not sure why people think Story “can’t” return to SS. Whether or not he should is another matter, but is there some reason he just is physically unable to? As for the rest of the lineup - the need probably 2b, 2 OF and a DH. DH might wind up being Casas. And Enmanuel Valdez might even be in the mix for 2b. But with no close OFs, I hope the Sox focus on players with good OBP and defense…
  7. notin
    They also have Cincinnati. And they have 6 games against the Yankees, whom they have beaten 4 times in their last 5 games…
  8. notin
    That’s been one of my points in the 2023 thread
  9. notin
    That was just pathetic
  10. notin
    That’s what I was thinking but it’s moot now…
  11. notin
    Duran should run here
  12. notin
    I stand by this…
  13. notin
    Only in September. They were a lot of fun for 5 months…
  14. notin
    I know he has a checkered past, but when McGuire comes up he’s been able to make good things happen…
  15. notin
    Bear in mind Dalbec is replacing an injured player there now…
  16. notin
    They shouldn’t sign Devers because Mookie got away. That’s actually why they extended Bogaerts (good) and Sale (awful). That’s not how a GM should build a team. They should extend Devers because he’s a young player capable of being a foundation you build a team around for the next several seasons…
  17. notin
    Are there better FA options to go large and long on? To me, Devers outranks the field…
  18. notin
    Out of curiousity, what was the consensus about Bloom after 2021?
  19. notin
    It was the best possible option. Unless you preferred Graterol…
  20. notin
    So? Bad grades on a trade equate to neither wins nor losses. Bottom line is the Sox had TWO options for Betts’ trades. Not three. Not 5. Not 29. Two. And neither option would have gotten a good grade. Keeping Betts actually would have been worse. The 2020 team would have still been without pitching. (Sale didn’t have TJ because Mookie got traded.) And maybe finished a tad higher, but not much. Then Betts walks for draft pick comp and Mayer doesn’t fall to Boston. And if Betts hits the open market, he can’t re-sign with Boston, because they would still be trying to reset. Plus they used his money on Bogaerts and Sale. Maybe he winds up in LA anyway. Or maybe, just maybe he does because the best offer puts him in pinstripes in the Bronx. But, hey, John Tomase didn’t like the trade. The “D” from San Diego would be better…
  21. notin
    Actually most trades like that yield far less long term. What did Baltimore get for Machado, for example? Verdugo alone made it a good trade for a short term superstar…
  22. notin
    I still liked Graterol better. Been saying that since December, 2020. But the Sox didn’t have as much leverage as you think. If the Dodgers balked, they could have just waited for 2020 to end and gotten Betts for the price of his extension and not given up anyone…
  23. notin
    I’m not so sure Eovaldi would have brought back a “good piece.” The only rental pitchers traded were Syndergaard, Jose Quintana, and Jordan Montgomery. Montgomery netted an injured Harrison Bader. The most notable player traded for the other two was Mickey Moniak, a former #1 overall pick that just hasn’t panned out…
  24. notin
    Not true. He was not ranked by BA nor by MLB.com until after the trade. BA had him at 86 pre-2020, 71 pre-2021. MLB.com had him at 44 pre-2020, 49 pre-2021…
  25. notin
    Mayer is in A ball, still years away. What Dombrowski did differed because he emptied the upper levels of any MLB-ready talent (while thankfully earmarking Devers as a keeper).
×
×
  • Create New...