Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

notin

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    53,362

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    45

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking

Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

News

2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by notin

  1. notin
    Why? Trout is owed close to $100mill more than all three of them combined and would be an excuse not to spend for much longer. Plus he might wind up playing fewer games than each of them, despite the longer deal. Less baseball for more money is the exact opposite direction the Sox need…
  2. notin
    One answer is investing more in the bullpen. High-priced starters often get higher AAVs, more years, pitch fewer innings than they used to, and at best can only influence 32 games. Higher priced relief pitchers cost less for fewer years and can influence 50-60 games. We talk about the rotations of the Padres and the Phillies that got them this far. But look at the rotations for the Mets, Tigers, and Guardians, and they’ve all gotten just as far…
  3. notin
    He’s his own worst enemy. He could probably play more often if he moved into a LF/DH role…
  4. notin
    Sure, he’s overpaid, but to call the scouting of him a failure? Seiya Suzuki received a slightly lower deal a year earlier at 2 years younger. Suzuki has adjusted better and is a better fielder, but both players were similar with the bat in Japan. So maybe Yoshida should have gotten 4 yrs/$64mill instead of 5/$90. Overpaid? Somewhat, but the overreactions are a little overboard, to put it mildly…
  5. notin
    I’m all on board with Tanner Scott, who I think should be the Sox top priority. Very hesitant on Fried or Burnes. The latter two will likely want 7-9 years, pitch effectively for maybe 2 or 3, and then spend the remainder of their contracts dragging down the payroll disallowing the Sox from replacing their production. Last year I wanted Sean Manaea, who turned out to be a great signing for the Mets on a one year deal. Manaea will likely now want a long term deal as well. Probably not loooking at 6-8 years, but he might get five. If the Sox want the 2025 Manaea - someone who can pitch effectively and not morph into an albatross for 3-4 (or more!) years, my first thought is Nick Martinez, who had a terrific second half for Cincinnati. Martinez would first have to opt out of his last year (at $12mill), but won’t be pushing the bidding into the 6-7 year range. Hard to see a team going beyond three…
  6. notin
    I’d rather have Rendon than Trout. At least his deal has only two years. But I’d rather have Yoshida than Rendon, so maybe the Angels aren’t the team to call…
  7. notin
    Trout has 6 years $223mill left on his contract and can’t stay on the field for 60 games. Also he reportedly insists he’s the starting centerfielder…
  8. notin
    A dangerous bat for at least 60 games…
  9. notin
    Not sure if he counts as Most Improved since he wasn’t with the Sox organization in 2023, but Cooper Criswell was certainly among the biggest surprises…
  10. notin
    A reboot of the 1984 World Series? With Tarik Skubal playing Jack Morris and Kerry Carpenter as Kirk Gibson. I do think casting Colt Keith and Javier Baez as Whitaker and Trammell were poor choices. I’m ok with Tatis as Tony Gwynn but Jake Cronenworth’s Steve Garvey feels shallow…
  11. notin
    I’m definitely in a minority but I wouldn’t mind if KC won and the media ignored the coolest streak in sports as LHRP Will Smith would win his 4th straight title with 4 different teams…
  12. notin
    And lost in Frazee’s legacy is he owned the team when they won the 1918 title. The 1919 team came in 6th and that preceded the sale of Babe Ruth…
  13. notin
    f*** Philadelphia. San Diego, baby. But ultimately as long as neither the Yankees nor Dodgers make it, and especially not both. An Ohtani-Judge World Series would make for insufferable television’…
  14. notin
    Watching the ones I can. Just not posting about it
  15. notin
    Well, it’s when Henry’s pact with Satan expires, if thats what you are referring to…
  16. notin
    Some is adjustment. Some is health/durability. People talk about him like the Sox put some Vince Papale type garbage man out there…
  17. notin
    Yoshida played 7 years in NPB with a career .960 OPS and 133 HRs. His numbers there were fairly comparable to Seiya Suzuki. It’s not like he was putting up Nick Punto numbers overseas. He just hasn’t hit as well as Suzuki so far…
  18. notin
    “Sustainable” also means “don’t get attached to young superstars that refuse team-friendly, long term deals early on in their service time”…
  19. notin
    Ok all of this was divulged prior to 2020 when they said they wanted to duplicate the Rays’ methods and start competing with a consistent pipeline of young talent that negated the need for eight-figure hired guns every year. They even hired a Rays’ front office guy to get it going (possible subtle hint). I think most of us didn’t want to believe it would take a few years to get the 29th/30th ranked farm system in place to do this, but in hindsight, this is clearly what happened…
  20. notin
    Until he added “this year we’re going FULL full throttle!!”
  21. notin
    2039-2040 off-season. I thought it was obvious…
  22. notin
    Cherington was likely more of an issue than Bloom, as Cherington’s commitments of some $280 mill (or so) to Hanley, Sandoval, and Rusney Castillo ultimately proved useless. I won’t count Porcello, because at least he worked out…
  23. notin
    Sale (and Bogaerts) signed after the Betts negotiations broke down. I got the impression they were Plan B. If any single existing contract prevented the Sox from signing Betts, the only one that makes sense is Price with its $31mill AAV that went through the end of 2022. Most likely it was the Big Picture with numerous 8 figure AAV deals including Price, Eovaldi, Martinez, Sandoval, Hanley and Rusney Castillo. Any others?
  24. notin
    Use the search on the boards…
  25. notin
    Can’t it be both?
×
×
  • Create New...