Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

notin

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    54,604

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    53

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking

Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

News

2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by notin

  1. notin
    Yoshida is certainly ready to DH. But I get the impression Cora is not wild about Yoshida sometimes…
  2. notin
    Would it be? A significant number of players change positions early in their career for any number of reasons. Can’t play old position. Old position blocked. Need someone for another position. Etc…
  3. notin
    You’re replying to a generic statement independent of Devers…
  4. notin
    If that were the case, the odd-fitting “Story to 1b” solution checks all the boxes. Especially since Story doesn’t complain when moved…
  5. notin
    Playing bad D doesn’t make you a bad teammate. But playing bad defense and refusing the manager’s requests to move you does…
  6. notin
    Cora originally wanted Bregman for 2b, not 3b. He’s been reluctant to move Devers multiple times this year. Is this because he wants Devers at 3b or because he knows Devers can be difficult? He has never expressed interest in upholding this alleged promise…
  7. notin
    So what was said? I keep asking. What if Bloom said “ as long as I’m here, you’re my third baseman”? Not that Breslow is accountable for Bloom’s verbal promises anyway. But more important, they gave him two years and Devers LOST THE JOB. At some point, isnt Devers accountable for his own play?
  8. notin
    So Devers gets the “not a bad teammate” vote from someone who’s not actually a teammate. Know who disagrees with you? His teammates. https://nypost.com/2025/05/09/sports/red-sox-teammates-reactions-revealed-as-rafael-devers-wages-war-against-front-office/ Devers got promised third base. And during two years, he lost the job by being the worst defensive third baseman in MLB. Everyone who was worse (aka Jake Burger) was moved off the position. If Devers could actually play third, he’d still be there…
  9. notin
    Like Kyle Schwarber did?
  10. notin
    1. What does “foreseeable future” mean? 2. So that promise exempts him from temporary moves? The Sox didn’t get a “real first baseman” because in today’s age of 8 man bullpens, you simply cannot put eight MLB caliber starting players on your bench. And Breslow didn’t sign Devers. Bloom did. Breslow was hired 8 months later….
  11. notin
    An arbitration-eligible first baseman with 350 PAs and a .770 OPS over the past two years is not going to be in demand this offseason…
  12. notin
    Baltimore might not be so ready to wave the white flag in May, especially early May.
  13. notin
    Miguel Cabrera came up as a SS and basically played wherever they told him, including the OF at one point. The 2024 Padres went to the NLCS with a lineup featuring 7 players they told to move off shortstop. Only Higashioka never played the position…
  14. notin
    True. Most first basemen in MLB move there. The ones who came up playing 1b fall into one of 4 physical categories . 1. Left-handed 2. Really tall 3. Both 4. Paul Goldschmidt and Pete Alonso
  15. notin
    Did Bryce Harper balk at 1b? Not sure. Did Blad Jr. say “I won’t “? I don’t know. I do know both moved…
  16. notin
    He absolutely might. As far as I’m concerned if/when that happens, all is forgiven…
  17. notin
    You might be right. Devers wasn’t the only MLB player this off-season to be vocal about his move to DH. Seiya Suzuki also did. Both situations contain a fair amount of parallels. Both teams acquired star players possibly for just one year, for example. And both players did move to DH. Assuming Cora wants Rafael there, if Devers eventually moves and this was just venting frustration, it’s fine with me. But if he adamantly refuses this temporary move, that does make him a problem..
  18. notin
    I don’t agree with Brock’s assessment that Devers couldn’t play 1b, but I do see why Devers is upset. He’s basically being told “you suck at 3b.” But it’s time for some reality. He does. He’s in MLB solely because he can hit at an elite level. If he hit like Romy Gonzalez - who is probably one of the best 500 hitters currently walking the face of the Earth - Devers isnt even a major leaguer…
  19. notin
    But what was promised? Third base for 10 years? Five years? No temporary moves (which this would clearly be since Casas is hurt, not dead)? Third base even if he bulks up to 400lbs and makes 200 errors? What was promised?
  20. notin
    And what was that exactly? For how long? Under all circumstances, not even temporary moves? Enlighten us… You’ve already thrown out the hypothetical scenario where Devers doesn’t sign without the promise. So why not put it in the contract? After all, a contract is just a promise in writing. And you’ve told us
  21. notin
    Gotta love the “they can’t expect me to play every position” hyperbole. I don’t think that’s the case here. While I sort of understand it, Devers needs to grasp eventually that as much as a lifetime of practice helped hit hitting, the fielding never caught up. No one wants him to play “every position”; they want to limit him to the least challenging ones defensively. And a move to 1b isnt even permanent. It’s not like Casas died…
  22. notin
    What was he lied to about? No one knows what he was promised…
  23. notin
    I gave him the benefit of the doubt. But I heard him whine (through his translator) yesterday….
  24. notin
    Right. Not having another MLB caliber first baseman just sitting on the bench is the problem here. You’re possibly the only person ever to complain about the Sox not having enough 1b/DH types..
  25. notin
    The only position hes been good at is DH. His defense devalues their investment. Well, that and his attitude…
×
×
  • Create New...