If Refsnyder retires, Eaton might be the RHH fourth OF, rather than putting Garcis in a role that maxes out around 40 games. Eaton will very likely be that guy that flops and returns to being the player he was pre-Boston, earning the disdain of many. But he certainly did earn the right to be that guy and flop for Boston.
Heres the thing. If you think Campbell has to earn his way back as if he never destroyed MiLB pitching and wasn’t the Offensive Rookie of the Month for April and think he’s no different than Corey Rosier at this point, and if you’ve gone to the extent of thinking Password is more likely or more worthy of making the roster than Campbell is, then you have given up on him. He’s not back at Square One; thr Sox extended him for a reason, and they knew at the time there was a good chance he struggled at some point (I mean, he was struggling when they extended him.), but they did it because they had enough faith in him to overcome whatever obstacles he faced…