notin
-
Posts
55,280 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
56
Content Type
Profiles
Boston Red Sox Videos
2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospect Rankings
Boston Red Sox Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Boston Red Sox Fan Guides & Resources
2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Boston Red Sox News, Rumors & Analysis
2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by notin
-
It's always funny when people try to justify the new hype as being radically different from the old identical hype. It is a VAST understatement to say Montero was only considered a 1B/DH type, Yankee fans were spouting he was the next Miguel Cabrera on a vriety of message boards. He was a BA Top 10 prospect 3 times. There was a lot of "can't miss" in the hype. Of course, he did miss. By a lot. It was a really bizarre deal when he was dealt for Pineda, being a rarity that two young, controllable high profile players were swapped for each other. And Pineda was clearly the better get, but he was also - and apparently still is - a walking DL stint. He missed so much time it was difficult to keep track of how long he was with the Yankees. Torres might be great. But if he can't hit, he might end up as a utility infielder. Or, if you prefer, a utility infielder who could have gotten you Gerrit Cole...
-
Is that really any better than Musgrove, Feliz, Martin and Moran? Bear in mind, they reportedly liked Martin to some extent. I really doubt Deven Marrero would make a difference in any trade either way. (Yet I would keep him on the 25-man roster ahead of Holt.)
-
Tough call, but as Benintendi, Devers and Moncada both have starting jobs, they seem les likely to be backups...
-
MLB-readiness is the new thing. Teams are apparently sick of getting burned by high upside A-ball guys who flame out before AA. I don't think Marrero or Lin really have anything in terms of trade value. Every team in MLB has good glove/no bat infielders rapidly running out of options. Really, there is nothing in that offer that looks more appealing than Colin Moran, and the best chance the Sox would have had would be to include Chavis. Even then, maybe Pittsburgh doesn't like him. But it's a safe bet no matter how they feel about him, they like him better than they like Marrero or Lin...
-
As would any team. But the weird thing is trying to guess the two all stars. The way Montero was being talked up, one would have thought he was an obvious choice back then. (And while Betances has been an All star closer, he as a starer considered less than Banuelos.) Similar to how Torres is being talked up this year. Cashman didn't hold Montero, and it arguably worked out, I guess. But he has been far more adamant about Torres despite one of the better GMs in the league already dealing him for a rental player...
-
Well, for starters because that package is vastly inferior. Musgrove (1.7 fWAR in 171 IP) to date has been less effective than ERod (5.0 fWAR in 366 IP), but has an extra year of control. Feliz has outperformed Hembree, albeit marginally. Both have similar control left. But that leaves Deven Marrero as a the counter-offering to both Colin Moran and Jerry Martin, who were both ranked in the top 13 of a better Astros system. The Pirates wouldn't take that offer if you held held Neal Huntington's kids for ransom. And Marrero has the added bonus of being out of options. He actually might be a good add over Jordy Mercer at SS, but players as good as Marrero will be available on the market for very cheap deals. If you replaced Marrero with Chavis and add a player like Cole Brannen or Bobby Dalbec, you're at least almost there...
-
64 days to opening day, 142 free agents remain unsigned. The frenzy is coming any day now...
-
Me neither. Although if I'm Peter Bourjos' agent, I'm calling right now. More likely they will try to move one of their contract players for another outfielder under contract. A trade of Mark Melancon (4 years $62mill) for Juan Lagares (4 years $23mill) would improve their OF and buy them some wiggle room, and actually make sense for both teams. They might also try to move Joe Panik someplace for a cheaper OF who is better than Jackson. (Panik to Mil for Keon Broxton?) But unless they can move Cueto or Samardzija, I don't see them in on Martinez...
-
Only because he gets hurt all the time...
-
With what?
-
I don't think they signed Jackson to start. He's the type of fourth outfielder the Sox should be looking for. (Although if I'm Austin Jackson, I sign with SF long before I think about Boston. Much easier outfield to get a starting job in.)
-
Because Boras has clearly been in a hurry so far this off-season...
-
Of course if you flip over to the General Baseball Forum, you will see a thread titled "Baseball America Top 100" started by Jacksonianmarch some time ago. The first entry in that thread is about the Yankees having six of the top 100 prospects. Four of those six (Montero, Brackman, Banuelos, and Romine) were complete flops. Romine, a career backup catcher, has been the most successful of these four. A little perspective...
-
Sort of like how the Dodgers, while they always seem to have a good farm, have developed this new knack for taking utility infielders and turning them into All Stars...
-
He was significantly higher on Devers than BA was too. ..
-
Sure. Probably a couple dozen But I doubt any of the higher tier free agents will and risk being lesser fallback options in next year's class...
-
Hosmer is not going to sign for $121mill for 6 years when he has already turned down $140million for 7 years. Unless he foolishly thinks he can get another deal worth $19mill at age 34...
-
But those same writers have called him - direct quote here - the biggest landmine in this free agent class. He will be massively overpaid and for far too long. He's already turned down seven years. And he will be a huge reason why the Sox have to let some younger players go eventually. I'd just assume go for the shorter deal and save up for Betts...
-
While I'm not wild about it, until he signs elsewhere, you really can't take Hosmer off the Plan B list. ..
-
While I'm not wild about it, until he signs elsewhere, you really can't take Hosmer off the Plan B list. ..
-
Double post. Also lousy "Delete" feature. ..
-
A Gold Glove caliber defender on a 3 year deal? Once someone actually signs, that contract might look really sweet. But as of now, there are about 180 unsigned free agents and only 66 days until the season opens. A lot of these players will retire (involuntarily?), but there is a lot of signing action that should start happening any day now. In theory. ..
-
The list is out. Only two Red Sox (Groome and Chavis) in the top 100. None in the top 80..
-
Hanley had an OPS+ of 189 when he was JD's age last year...
-
But whose going to light a fire under the slightly-above-average Hosmer?
