Ever seen Dombrowski’s first 4 years in Detroit? The team averaged about 60 wins per season. Does that mean he did a horrible job too? Or should we take into account what he was taking over?
Cherington took over a team that quit on the manager and owner. He had talent but he also had a lot of attitude problems. His first season was a last place one, but isn’t his reset button trade a huge factor there? He managed to unload some horrific contracts, one of which I believe is still current.
Then he won a World Series one year later. In 2014, the same team that won the Series came in last. While expecting a repeat was probably too much, did anyone expect last place? I expected at the very least that that team should have been competitive.