Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

notin

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    55,249

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    56

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospect Rankings

Boston Red Sox Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Boston Red Sox Fan Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Boston Red Sox News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by notin

  1. notin
    Boy, you really aren’t a Perfect Little Pacifist
  2. notin
    The cautionary tale is that in 2000, you could have made a similar post about Nomar Garciaparra, who, if not for a broken hamate bone, likely exceeds Betts’ WAR through his first 5 seasons. And afterwards was really never the same player again. I know future injuries won’t be a factor when Betts’ contract time comes, but there is always the possibility of an equally tragic outcome. As Sox fans, we’ve seen two of the best players to come up in our farm system before Betts to become completely derailed by them. The Sox got lucky with Nomar, but even today fans still want Pedroia to retire because he’s sucking up precious cap room while failing to be the player he used to be...
  3. notin
    Then why did you start with 30-30?
  4. notin
    That the Sox starting pitching has underwhelmed is not a revelation....
  5. notin
    No real numbers have been made public, but I imagine if he stays even close to last year’s pace, he’ll ask closer to Trout than Harper. I do think not being 26 when his time comes might be a big factor, but he still gets somewhere between Arenado and Machado for cash and years...
  6. notin
    I think we all hope they do, Dombrowski included. But I do think this argument needed a Devil’s Advocate....
  7. notin
    Oh definitely. I doubt any team has ever traded a 26yo superstar and not faced backlash, regardless of what they got back. In fact, I’m trying to think of a single instance of trading a young superstar and the return was even worth it ...
  8. notin
    The Sox have had several players who accomplished the feat with other teams. Harper, Kinsler, Canseco, Hanley Ramirez, Grady Sizemore, Brandon Phillips, Ellis Burks and Jeff Bagwell...
  9. notin
    Apparently the former Sox shortstop prospect is being converted to a pitcher by the Padres. In his first bullpen session, he threw multiple pitches that are clocked at 100mph...
  10. notin
    Hal Chase was Pete Rose before Pete Rose, with the added bonus of intentionally throwing games he bet on and bribing players on other teams to do the same...
  11. notin
    But then Hample does run a charity that gives baseball and softball equipment to underprivileged kids...
  12. notin
    That would be Charles Comiskey, who refused to pay his players well and allegedly denied them opportunities to reach performance bonuses, most notably ace pitcher Eddie Cicotte, who was supposedly denied multiple opportunities to get his 30th win which would trigger a $10,000 bonus. (His salary was $6,000.). Not sure if the benching is true, but his game logs indicate he was pulled after 2 innings in his last game with a 2-1 lead...
  13. notin
    Yeah but is he considered a “generational talent” because he accomplished something Ian Kinsler has done twice? 30-30 is tremendous, but he had fewer home runs and stolen bases than Jose Ramirez last year...
  14. notin
    But he won’t command the same return one year later. He’d still get a good package, but not a monster one...
  15. notin
    Or “two”, if you like being correct...
  16. notin
    Tend to agree. It’s hard to label Betts as a once-in-a-lifetime layer when he’s a contemporary of Mike Trout and the younger fast tracked Ronald Acuna and Juan Soto, both of whom might be inspiring the phrase “Mookie who?” by the time they turn 26...
  17. notin
    Let’s get hypothetical. Say the Sox are 10 (or more) games out on July 31 and this season looks lost. Maybe injuries have piled up. Betts has resisted all attempts to sign an extension and is looking for Trout money (although Arenado money might be more realistic). With 1 and a half seasons left, his value is never going to be higher. What if the Dodgers offer a package built around Alex Verdugo and Julio Urias, with others? Still pass? What if Corey Seager (whom they went to a World Series without last year) was one of those others? Still no? (Again, hypothetical. Not expecting these exact returns.)
  18. notin
    Andujar here...
  19. notin
    I know you’re joking, but that would make his playing life suck. Imagine all the grumbling from every teammate dissatisfied with his contract...
  20. notin
    The definition of the word “several” is “more than two but not many.” New York schools, I guess....
  21. notin
    Throw in the AL Central Default Champions and those teams are 4-10 with a -18 run differential...
  22. notin
    I would also argue that, much like in the cases of Porcello and Jason Hayward, age was also a factor...
  23. notin
    Long is usually my sticking point, too. But players like Cano, Votto, Cabrera and Pujols were signing deals into their 40s at that time...
  24. notin
    Ah... “pharmaceutical expenses”...
  25. notin
    That’s funny. So JD Martinez in your eyes clearly learned NOTHING about free agency from his own “cautionary tale” and will definitely opt out a full year before his salary even drops. But Chapman will look at the outrageous demand from a pitcher he undoubtedly thinks is a lesser closer anyway, and decide he will do what’s best for the Yankees? Got it...
×
×
  • Create New...