I give more credence to second wild card teams than some of these division winners.
The 2006 Cardinals went 83-78, but made the postseason solely because the rest of the NL Central couldn’t even win 83 games. The Cardinals won on the basis of having similar geography to a bunch of shittier teams. They also got lucky in October and won the WS.
But because they were the least incompetent team out of 6 (yes, 6 back then) in the NL Central, they were a legitimate postseason team? The Phillies, White Sox, Angels, Blue Jays and Red Sox all won more games than the Cardinals (while playing in divisions with better teams) and missed the playoffs...