Disagree. Yes, he may fall off some but even if he falls off to 35 homers a year, it’s still more power than exists on the Sox roster now. Right now, he’s certainly capable of 40+ for the next couple years. He’s even acknowledged that DH is likely to be his future position.
Plus the guy has been durable as can be. In 6 seasons excluding the Covid year (where he still played 57 of 60 games), he’s never played less than 152 games in a season, and only twice has played less than 160. The last two years, he’s played all 162.
Once again, they lowball someone so they can claim they tried. Let’s face it, Henry is a cheap prick and nothing’s going to happen otherwise until he sells the team. They’ll lowball Anthony when his deal is up and he’ll move on or be moved on. Same with anyone else who figures to make major $.