He just too unpredictable on so many levels- from offense to defense to emotional, mental and body type (Physical).
He changed positions.
He changed his stance and approach more than any player I have ever seen, and it's just been 6 seasons, including two tiny sample size ones.
He missed the road trip to TOR during COVID. He's had numerous run-ins with fans. He's had countless base-running and defensive, mental blunders.
He's had stretches, some very long, where he looks like a top 15 to 20 everyday player in MLB. Other times, he looks average. Still others, he looks totally lost- both on O and D.
Nothing in baseball is predictable, but you try and get as close to it as you can, and with this guy, it's impossible.