Quoting moon:
There were "signs" he was doing well in '21 just like in '23. The only reason it's a big deal is that Sale finally did not get hurt, after 5 years, and somehow we should have known that was going to happen, based on how he looked for a stretch in 2023.
"Somehow we should have known" is a totally unfair way to put it. It would be ridiculous for anyone to say the Sox should have known Sale would have a season like this. I really don't think anyone has said any such thing.
The issue is with the possibility he could have a good season. -bellhorn
Yes, saying there was a possibility is a good way of putting it.
There was a possibility before 2019, before 2020, before 2021, before 2022, before 2023 and before 2024.
Since many posters are upset we didn't guess right for 2024, I think using the phrase "somehow we should have known" captures the sentiment, too.
We guessed rong 5 straight years, and had we traded hi before 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 or 2023, and he went on to do what he did in those seasons, nobody would be complaining.
We did after 2023, and he is doing very well. We guessed wrong, and Brez is being roasted for NOT going with the possibility he might do well. He guessed wrongly. ATL guessed right.
Yes, it was totally random, and we picked the exact wrong year to trade Sale. In hindsight, it was a 1 in 6 chance, and we picked the one. (And, we paid to guess wrongly, too.)