I'm not "advocating" Grissom. I prefer DHam-Romy at 2B to end the season.
I only am arguing that it made sense to want to try and upgrade 2B- our very worst position since 2018: worse than SP1, SP2, SP3, SP4, SP5, RP1-8 and every other position.
Tell me, why that does not make sense?
Now, clearly the pitching, as a whole, was our biggest weakness, but that does not mean it makes zero sense to try and upgrade 2B, and I think their belief was Gio would start 29-33 games, while Sale would start 5-20 games, AND we'd be better at 2B. The idea made sense. The results did not work.
I'm not sidestepping anything. I know who we got for Sale has sucked.
I know Sale is having the best season of any SP'er in 2024.
I know Gio has started zero games in 2024.
Nobody is disputing we failed on all three levels. That does not change the fact that the attempts made SOME sense, at the time.
Easily, one or two of the 3 things I listed might have been different, and this whole debate would never have happened.
To me, the biggest shocker of the 3 was the 34 year Sale about to win the Cy Young after 5 straight seasons of let-downs.
The Gio zero starts was an easy 2nd.
Grissom's poor 2024 is a distant 3rd.
I'll also add that if DHam and Romy had not shocked the hell out of all of us and replaced the Valdez-Reyes middle infield utility crew, we would be talking about how 2B has been a big reason we are 10 GB the WC race, right now, because we might have been that far back, now.
I'm not gonna blame Brez for not knowing DHam was going to do this, either. I mean what was he, our 4th string middle infielder in March?