Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

moonslav59

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    104,574

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    129

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking

Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

News

2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by moonslav59

  1. moonslav59
    I'm terrible with knowing how good our pitching prospects will turn out. I hardly ever see them live, and go mostly by scouting reports and stats, so that's one reason. I know we lack any great hopes, except maybe Perales, but I think we might have a few more Houck's, Bello's or Crawford's up our sleaves.
  2. moonslav59
    Mayer, Abreu, Wong, Crawford & Wikelman for Ober (3 arbs), Ryan (3 arbs) and Jeffers (1 arb)
  3. moonslav59
    Kimbrel was really his first move (NOV '15) followed by Chris Young and Price in early DEC. That Price signing shocked the hell out of me, and others. Midseason '16: traded Rijo & Wilkerson for Aaron Hill and traded Basabe & Almonte for Brad Ziegler, then Espinoza for Pomeranz. At the deadline, Pat Light for Fernando Abad. 2nd offseason (Fall '16-Spring '17): Dubon, Shaw & Pennington for Thornburg and the big shocker: 4 players for Chris Sale. Selected Josh Rutledge Rule 5. Singed Mitch Moreland. Traded Buch for Josh Tobias. Paid cash for Hector Velazquez. 2017 midseason: Doug Fister off waivers. Traded Longhi, I Diaz & S Espinal for IFA bonus pool space. Traded Shaun Anderson & G Santos for Nunez and then 3 prospects for Addison Reed. 3rd offseason ('17-'18): Re-signed Moreland & Nunez. Signed JD Martinez. Midseason: Santiago Espinal for Steve Pearce, then Beeks for Nate. Also, Buttrey & Jerez for Kinsler 4th off season and his last: Quiroz for Colten Brewer (effectively Kimbrel & Kelly's replacement) Extended Sale & Bogaerts. Midseason: Cash for Andrew Cashner
  4. moonslav59
    Even if they went to 7 game series in each round, there is no need to cut back that much, and they'd never give up that amount of money over a concept. Going to 154 would just return to the old days, so it would not be that extreme, but my guess is they will stay at 162, while still expanding the playoffs.
  5. moonslav59
    I do think we might match up with MN, if they are looking to trade Lopez or some of their soon-to-be arb pitchers. I'd like to see us get Jeffers, their RHB catcher with 1 year of control left. He also averages about 28 HRs per 650 PAs. Get it done!
  6. moonslav59
    I get that Rafaela played 14 more innings at SS than OF, but his 634 OF innings was 140 more than Ref and 633 more than Yoshida. I like the grades given. I'd have made some minor adjustments: A+ Duran A- Abreu B+ O'Neill and Ref C Rafaela INC Yoshida
  7. moonslav59
    I don't trust what any of these guys say. They could go to 14, soon, then 16, if and when they expand to 32.
  8. moonslav59
    True but more than half get in. (I'm not for the idea.)
  9. moonslav59
    While I do think 154 games is enough to weed out lucky teams, I agree. The long season is for a reason. Asking teams to win short series after short series adds back in the luck factor, or as some call it "a crapshoot." Baseball is not like basketball and football. The playoffs should not be like theirs.
  10. moonslav59
    Great point and list. Much had nothing to do with a radical cut in winter spending. While the payroll went up, as Maz keeps pointing out, much was due to arb raises and the extensions that just kept the status quo. There was basically no new spending after 2018, and any new spending in 2020 and 2021 never replaced what was lost, in terms of expiring contracts or players traded away (Betts, Price, Beni...) I will say, I do not think the nate extension was bad, but it wasn't as good as the JD signing or Kimbrell & Sale trade. The Bogey extension was great, despite the opt-out. I doubt we get him for $20M a year w/o that. We can say he should have worked to get a non opt out with Bogey and a Betts extension, but that is really speculating on things with too many moving parts.
  11. moonslav59
    Let's get their catcher back.
  12. moonslav59
    Kinsler did solidify the 2B defense, as Nunez looked pretty bad out there. There were also guys like Brasier, who did very well under DD.
  13. moonslav59
    Agreed, and I'd say the same about the 2019 Sox. Sure, he let Kimbrell and kelly walk without replacing them, but he was accused of overkilling it on the 2018 team, so blaming him for 2019 seems far-fetched, to me. It also begs the question about how high were expectations going into 2014 or 2022. If you look at the 2021 roster and consider Bloom added Wacha, Strahm, Hill and got our best season out of Schreiber and Story in '22, one can wonder why it all turned so sour. On paper, it looks like the winter moves should have helped.
  14. moonslav59
    He should not be blamed for being handed a massive budget to work with. He did pretty well with his biggest contracts, although the Price deal lessened the return we got for Betts. The Sale extension hurt, but to me, it made more sense at the time than the Yoshida signing plus deals like Gio+Kluber+ Richards + Perez x 2. One major criticism he got, at the time was "emptying the farm," or "leaving it barren." Call it luck on some of his guys, but the fact is he kept maybe the best 6 out of 6 or 7 prospects. Devers, Houck, Duran, Crawford, Rafaela, Beni He drafted or IFA signed: Houck, Duran, Casas, Crawford (most were not high draft picks) Bello, Rafaela (IFAs) Shugart, Murphy, Bastardo, Wikelman, B Gonzalez Shaun Anderson (traded for Nunez), Scherff (for Robles), Blaylock (for Urias) Quiroz (for Brewer) This is better than decent, considering lower draft picks.
  15. moonslav59
    That would be a good idea, but I think they'd need a 27 man roster with 28 for Sundays. The union would likely insist on this, and with good reason. If you teams a day off every week, but play a double header every Sunday, teams would play 7 games a week, and the season would be 162 days long + the AS break. The season could be 24 weeks long. That's about 3 weeks less than now, so in theory, teams could get another day off 3rd week and play 20 games in 21 days.
  16. moonslav59
    I like a lot of MN's higher-priced players. Buxton's injuries turn me off, bigtime, but if taking on his salary greatly reduces the return, I'd consider taking the RHB and returning LHBs and prospects, pre-arb and arb guys to get some good pitching. Carlos Correa: $37.3M x 3 ($33.3M tax hit) NOPE Byron Buxton (Mr. Injury) $15.1M x 4 ($14.3M tax hit) DOUBTFUL Pablo Lopez: $21.75M x 3 (but $18.4M tax hit) A BIG YES Joe Ryan & Bailey Ober both have 3 arbs left. I'm not sure why MN wants to trade them, now. Both BIG YES Ryan Jeffers RHB catcher has his 3rd arb due. He seems like a perfect fit to bridge to Teel. BIG YES BTV: 44 Joe Ryan (value back in May) 37 Lopez 23 Ober 22 Correa 13 Jeffers 0 Buxton So, Lopez + Jeffers= 50, Ryan + Jeffers =57 and Ober + Jeffers=36. I doubt we'd pry two SP'ers away, so one plus Jeffers looks like a great match for the Sox side of the trade. I'm not sure who they like on the Sox, but maybe if we took on Buxton's salary, they'd want Abreo ($29M.) DHam has $11M value, but that seems too high. He did very well at 2B D and has speed, but I'm not sure a .700 OPS (the new .750) is good enough to make those two worth $50M. They might take Mayer for Lopez + Jeffers or Mayer + Dobbins for Ryan + Jeffers. Abreu+DHam might get Ober + Jeffers. Hard to know what other teams might offer, too.
  17. moonslav59
    There is just too much money in playoff games to decide not to do it. Maybe we go to 14 first.
  18. moonslav59
    If we count Thornburg, then do we count Moreland and Nunez as good? How about Kinsler? Do we count the Pearce ext as major (and bad?) Lots of gray area. I do think it's clear DD did better with major deals then B & B (and add Ben, if you want.) Of course, spending $20+M on JD & Bogey gives you a better chance at success or meh, than spending 5-10M on 1 year deals.
  19. moonslav59
    Okay, 90% was too high a number to throw out there. You are right, but... I'd say the Nate extension and PomPom trade were a meh's. I'm not sure the Thornburg trade was a "major deal." Price was close to a meh. Not extending someone is pushing it, since Betts refused to extend. The Sale extension failed. Thornburg was a miss, but I would not count that, but since Shaw did well for a couple years, I guess you can count it. If you count all the non-extensions, then Bloom & Brez's 25% becomes more like 15-20%. HIT: Sale trade, Kimbrell, JD, Bogey ext., Nate trade, Pearce, Moreland & Nunez (not major) MEH: Price (close to bad) Nate ext, Pomeranz BAD: Sale ext. & Chris Young, Thornburg (not major?) Deciding what is major or not is up for debate. I could have counted Re3nfroe and Strahm as plusses for Bloom, but then the JBJ trade, Andriese, Sawamura, Marwin and others as bad ones. too. I see about 5-7 hits for DD, 2-3 mehs and 1-2 bad. That's 8-10 Good to meh and 1-2 bad. One could argue 9-1, but 8-2 is maybe better. So 80% to 25% in DD's favor. Maybe 70% to 20%.
  20. moonslav59
    Then expand the roster to 27 or 28 players (+1 for DBLHDRs) and have less days off.
  21. moonslav59
    We've had 5 years of about a 25% hit on our GMs biggest deals: Pivetta, Turner, Duvall, Jansen & Martin: HIT Kike I, Ottavino, Wacha & Hill: Meh Giolito, Grissom, Kluber, Yoshida, Story, Richards, Barnes ext, .M Perez I, M Perez II, Kike II, Paxton: Yuck-a-doodle-doo-doo! You can count DD's bad moves on just 2-3 fingers.
  22. moonslav59
    Interesting idea. BTV has him at 37, which is less than Abreu + DHam, but I'm sure they'd hang up on that call. They may want to trade RHB Buxton, but he's always hurt. He's worth 0.4 on BTV. Would Abreu,DHam and Dobbins (Fitts) get the job done?
  23. moonslav59
    -69 Story (owed $77.5M) -24 Yoshida (better than I thought, as we could "save $30M" by trading him and worth more than Castillo on BTV.) -23 Giolito (worth less than he's owed.) -15 Whitlock (seems steep) -8 Hendriks (owed $4M) -7 Rafaela
  24. moonslav59
    I'd rather have Campbell or Mayer at 3B (and 2B) and use the money on pitching.
  25. moonslav59
    It was bold. It back-fired, no doubt, but it was a big trade- something Bloom did not do since being forced to deal Betts. I guess trading Beni was kinda bold. 1 semi-bold trade in his last 3.5 years. Instead, he let guys walk in free agency. Lovely!
×
×
  • Create New...