He's killed us in every slot.
fangraph's projected aOPS (400+ PAs)
.803 Anthony
.788 Abreu
.785 Contreras
.762 Duran
.746 Durbin (not even close to #4.)
.725 Rafaela (not close)
.713 Story (not close)
When I said "we" I was speaking to the general feeling, and I'm not nor ever have been "big on" Duran.
His speed made him a top 3-4 offensive player. He's 50 points below his projected OBP, and it made sense to see how he did batting first, once Anthony was no longer available. I do blame Cora for sticking with him for so long, but not for trying him there.
Look, I wanted to trade him. I just don't see everything as black & white. The argument that we shouldn't trade one of our projected top offensive players made some sense... just as it made some sense at the time to trade away a pitcher like Sale who was hurt all the time.
I suggested we trade Duran for Paredes, Janek and a RP'er, and many here felt that was an overpay. From what I hear, HOU didn't even want Duran one for one, so I'm really not sure what was offered for him last DEC-JAN.
I wish we'd have traded him after 2024, but hell, I was for trading him before 2024, so I'm no fortune teller either.