If AR just gives us meh, then of course, how the players we give up do is going to be how the final grade is measured.
If AR does well, but not great, then that changes things somewhat.
If he does very well, despite no ring, I think the return players shouldn't matter much, but if Eyanson wins a Cy Young then...
If AR helps us win a ring, it doesn't matter what the others do, to me.