I feel good about our chances to make the playoffs, and when you consider that 3 SP'ers usually get about 80-90% of all playoff starts, I think that gives us a boost. I think we can compete with our top 3 starters, and Tolle might be a plus #4.
fWAR Rankings by AL contenders:
DET: 1 Skubal, 21 Flaherty, 29 Mize
NYY: 5 Fried, 16 Rodon, 23 Warren
BOS: 2 Crochet, 25 Bello, 32 Giolito
HOU: 3 Brown, 4 Valdez, 58 Walter (big drop off)
SEA: 13 Woo, 20 Gilbert, 28 Castillo, 30 Kirby
TOR: 14 Gausman, 22 Bassitt, 36 Berrios
Even without Anthony, the bottom of our order looks better than most teams, and if we get Abreu back & healthy, maybe the top and middle of our orser can keep pace with other AL contenders with bigger star power.