Then the bashing has been misplaced.
I'm a huge Cora fan, but keeping Kike at leadoff was worthy of heavy criticism.
Kike is hitting 80 points below his career norm, but most of the league is 20-50 below, so in that context, Kike may not deserve even moderate criticism.
I was a big supporter of trying Arroyo at lead off, which Cora did a couple times, but even he has not gotten on base all that much in the last week or two, so it's hard to show that position was a sure winner.
I think we all kind of believe Renfroe should stay hitting behind the big 4, so leading him off, or putting Verdugo 1st and Renfroe somewhere else in the top 5, may not have helped much, either. That would also create an even worse 6-9 potion of the order.
It's not such an easy call for Cora. Sure, in hindsight, we can scream "Anyone is better than Kike or Santana!" and we'd probably be right, but nobody know who will be hot going forward. Look at the Dalbec example.
Here is a look at some chosen sample sizes and OBP...
(Note Arroyo's OBP in the last week)
Last 7 days
.316 Vaz (Never heard a sould advocate Vaz leading off)
.308 Marwin (We were all in shock when Cora put him leading off)
.294 Kike (Better than Arroyo by 63 pts)
.231 Arroyo
.231 Santana (equal to Arroyo, surprisingly)
How about the week before (Yes! to Arroyo!)
.391 Vaz
.360 Arroyo
.310 Kike
.136 Marwin
.125 Santana
The week before last...
.385 Arroyo
.286 Marwin
.278 Vaz
.136 Santana
.125 Kike
May 23-29
.333 Cordero
.333 Marwin
.300 Santana
.211 Kike
.143 Arroyo (Cora was supposed to know Arroyo would heat up by this?)
May 16-22
.500 Arauz (4 PAs)
.444 Chavis (9 PAs)
.421 Vaz
.381 Kike (Maybe this is why they left him leading off the next week)
.333 Santana
.250 Cordero
.118 Marwin
May 9-15 (no winners, this week)
.333 Arauz (6 PA)
.280 Marwin
.250 Chavis
.174 Vaz
.118 Cordero
(Kike & Arroyo on IL)
May 2-8
.636 Plawecki
.500 Vaz
.500 Kike (right before IL)
.333 Cordero
.321 Marwin
.143 Arroyo
Is there any rhyme or reason to these trends?
If we go by how well someone did the previous week or two, we'd be flipping a coin.
Nobody jumps out as having a consistently high OBP. Nobody.
.071 Vaz