If we really want to make a significant change to our defense, we have to look at doing more than just one of the following things:
1) Replace Bogey at SS (trade him or move him to 3B or 2B). He's going to opt out after 2022.
2) Replace Vaz at catcher. I know many disagree, but I think we need a change, here. He's a FA after 2022, so take the $7M option and trade him?
3) Consider moving Devers to 1B or even 2B. Half is errors are throwing. His bat is too important to trade away.
4) Keep Kike in CF as much as possible, so that means adding a solid infield utility player to cover for Arroyo at 2B. Hope we do better than Marwin.
5) Improve RF defense. Yes, Renfroe's arm has made up for a lot of his errors, but it's also the non plays in RF that are hurting us. I'm not sure Verdugo is much of an improvement in RF, and losing Renfroe's bat would hurt. If Renfroe in LF and Verdugo in RF was better, I think Cora would have done that. (It's what I thought our OF was going to be, last winter.) I'm not sure we do this. I think we stick with Verdugo in LF (+), Kike in CF (++) and Renfroe in RF (-), but maybe we pick up a whiz defensive 4th OF'er (gasp, trade Duran?)
6) 1B defense has been a major issue, but I think we stick with Dalbec and hope his D continues to improve, there. I do think Devers could be a plus at 1B after just a short learning curve time, but Dalbec at 3B is a big gamble. He won't be our DH.
So, is the best option to improve our D to trade Bogey, Vaz and Duran and fill the SS, C and utility IF and OF slots with plus defenders?
C ______
1B Dalbec/Devers
2B Arroyo + ______
3B Devers? (Dalbec?) ______?
SS _______
LF Verdugo
CF Kike
RF Renfroe + ________