Story is significantly better on defense by every measure and is loved by The Fielding Bible.
I’ll take their word for it.
Baez may be the best choice.
And now, suddenly, some of the players Bloom picked up at the deadline and afterwards are playing much better, now. Schwarber was injured, started strongly then slumped until the big hit, today, but what about Robles and Davis, of late?
Iggy?
Shaw?
The two comps are meaningful because at least the parks played in were the same. The pitching was different, as were the batters, but if LD and hard hit % mean anything, then one can assume the defense is the main reason for the wide BAbip variance.
That’s how I took Max’s well presented point. The assumption has been that Bloom neglected the defense, but we all know he had limited resources and a team with many high need areas to address, including defense.
He tried to balance this with that and ended up with a competitive and exciting team to watch, that still has some weak areas... one being defense. The balancing has worked out, though.
Instead of paying Schwarber and Bogey, we could sign a plus O- plus D SS like Baez, Story or Correa, trade Bogey or move him to 2B and then spend anything left on pitching and more pitching.
Let’s compare our offense to our defense:
On offense, we are first in BAbip at .307 but it’s very close.
We earned much of that by also being 6th in hard hit % at 33.3% (0.2 from 3rd) and 10th in LD% at 21.1% (0.1 from 8th best).
Now, the defense:
We are 9th in lowest Hard hit ball % (just o.8 from the best) and are 14th in lowest LD% at 20.9%, yet the BAbip against blows others away at .323!!!