I liked the Contreras deal on day one. I've said all along, let's compare Willson to Alonso when 2026 is over. Where did I say it was questionable?
I said the Sox brass viewed him as the "complimentary" bat to the guy they felt was the #1 prize: Bregman. I also have felt viewing Bregman as the #1 prize was a mistake.
Also, 26 and 27 year olds are no longer "young." They should be prime or just months away from peak prime.
Okay, Anthony, Mayer and Early are young, but they are not the players dragging the team down. Counting on 3 young players like them is not unheard of, and BTW, we added IKF to cover for Mayer, have 5 OF/DHs to cover for Anthony and SP'er depth was viewed as one of the few plusses this team had to cover for Early.
Rafaela turns 25 in September and has played 355 MLB games and 425 minor league ones.
I guess you can count Durbin as "too young," and Early is the only pitcher under 27 on the ML roster. (I'm not counting Anderson with 3 IP at age 26.)
I don't think counting on youth was one of our major issues. It was not addressing the power issue, not timing a Duran trade correctly and maybe not adding a significant RP'er to the pen.