If we kept everyone but JBJ, I think our chances of making the playoffs next year are very good. If that allows us to reset, even better. That will allow Henry the luxury of spending more next year, without the higher penalties, while giving us another year to improve the farm. Yes, it will take longer to rebuild the farm that way, but with smarter, 2nd tier type contracts, the team can rebuild without necessarily being doomed to mediocrity.
Obviously, the farm would be replenished much quicker if we dealt away some of our players this offseason.