I am hearing some people criticizing this move, saying that we got crap in return for 2 pretty good relievers. IMO, these people are failing to realize or understand a few things.
1. What were they expecting to get back in return for Workman and Hembree, one of whom is a free agent at the end of the year, the other of whom is a free agent after next year? A Shane Bieber type pitcher was not walking through our door. Workman might be good, but he is not going to repeat last year's performance. Hembree is good, and often doesn't get the credit he deserves, but as a good reliever with 1 year of control, his value isn't that high. In his best season, he was worth 0.5 fWAR.
2. By all accounts, Pivetta has very good stuff but just hasn't been able to get the results. This is the type of pitcher who seems to be right up Bloom's alley. I think Bloom feels like he can get the results out of Pivetta that have been lacking so far. I'm not talking about Pivetta being an ace, but hopefully he'll be a solid middle of the rotation pitcher. Ditto Seabold.
3. The number of cost-controlled years. That alone makes this trade a good value. We are getting a combined 9-10 years of control in return for 1 year of control.
Bloom did well in getting two pitchers who can help us next year and in the future. This trade is not a steal, by any means. But it is a very good, solid trade.