Hitch

I have no idea what fanbase you're looking at - this one seems to be losing it's mind that we're only 10-10 at the moment and want to rip everything down and start again.

Causation does not equal correlation. And in this case the two examples shouldn't be conflated anyway. Correct me if I am wrong, but I don't believe that Cora came out last year and said Kutter's knee is fine. Nothing going on there. His performance is down to mechanical not physical issues. In fact, as far as I can remember, the severity of Kutter's knee situation only come out this winter? We can question whether he maybe should have had surgery in the off season (though everyone involved continues to suggests it isn't needed, and they probably know just a tad more about it all than us), but it is a different case to Devers. Management have come out and quite clearly stated it isn't this particular issue people keep bringing up. They're either lying or they are not. Which is different to trying to manage a condition on the quiet.

Okay, well first of all, one exclamation mark is perfectly sufficient. I feel like I'm being shouted at by a mad man here. Secondly, don't you think they will have got an MRI if the shoulder(s) were in bad shape? Do you think these organisations hire large medical departments with the idea of just winging it and using guess work? So it leaves us with only a few realistic scenarios here. - They have had the MRI and it's fine. And his lower than expected start is in fact, due to one of the several other reasons posters have been sure is causing the problem. - They have had the MRI and are lying to us. - They have not had the MRI because his shoulders are fine they don't need another one (to go with the one they had last year). Now you can believe whatever you like obviously, and clearly will, but let's not pretend like your opinions on the matter are clear fact and can't be challenged.

So your position is that Devers, the Red Sox and their medial staff are all lying to us that Devers shoulders are okay? And we keep playing him despite the fact he's hurt?

What did you want them to do about Story exactly? Having a respected veteran with a top prospect backing him up is not a terrible spot. But what should Breslow have done at SS? He can't move that contract. Nobody is taking our expensive, injury prone player on. There's also a fair bit of revisionism going on with Casas. I was one of few who wanted him traded. Most thought he was a potential 30-40 HR guy. To say we haven't sorted 1B is a little off. We tried to trade him, found out the league dosesnt see the same value and we went with the kid with supposed big upside. Masa - clearly we couldn't give him away.. You're acting like it's a computer game and we should just fix whatever deficiencies we have because we can. There's things to fix but we've got a couple of bad contracts, players rated higher by our fans than other GMs and fixing everything takes time.

Let's hope April's Braves are also May's Braves.

Enjoyed the two very different wins the last two nights. Also, quietly very impressed with Story's start to the year. Hopefully the offence can pick it up until Bregman gets back and Casas remembers he can hit again.

How very dare she.

Well that and targeting unrealistic returns like Woo.

I thought we may have been nearing peak insanity yesterday, but I must say I am enjoying this idea that our now cataclysm (8-10) of a start is down to a soft generation and collective-is-better mindset. No word on how this new observation exists in a universe in which the same aged players from the same generation are winning, but with some luck there'll be another blowout tonight and we'll get to see just how far we can ride this pony!

He's 5'7 I believe. Not ideal, but I also believe Casas' height is helping him none right now and we might need to start thinking creatively soon.

By all reports they tried often to trade him but couldn't get the price they wanted. I've never understood the love for Casas, but he's ours now either way. His trade value is nothing. Can't break out of a slump unless you're played I guess.

But surely, the data tells you on 2 strikes to shorten the swing and get the ball in play? That's about as much a percentage shoe-in as you can get you'd think? Yet for whatever reason, we just are not doing it. The strike outs are ugly beyond the numbers. They're flat out ugly looking, too. It's fair to raise questions about how the team is being coached. It's difficult to imagine that the players are being told over and over to shorten swings and do different things, just to not when they play. But who knows.

Grissom has been playing 2B down there hasn't he? I'd like to see him get reps at 1st. I could definitely get behind Yoshi at 1st base if he can handle it.

If the posters approach your door with news about a long lost uncle tonight... I'd sit this one out.

Fantastic post. Might read again.

You've talked yourself into us needing to trade Duran to bring up two kids (how you get to the point of trading him out of that list you've mentioned above is beyond me but there we go). And you seem to be basing a lot of this on the fact 'we looked better with the kids in the team in Spring Training'. Spring Training! Sorry that is just panicked, bordering on insane, thinking, We're in mid April. 17 games in. 1.5 behind in the standings despite the world ending apparently. Just take a breath and let a bit of time play out. Anthony will likely come up when they'll no longer have a problem service time wise . Mayer might, too, though he doesn't have an open spot to play right now and is hitting 567 OPS in his first dozen games in AAA. This idea that they will inject everything this team needs and suddenly everyone will hit with RISP, lower strikeouts, and give better-at-bats is so counter-productive. The minute they struggle (and God forbid if they struggle out the gate as a great deal of prospects do), they'll get hammered and the complaints will start about us needing to have traded them, and prospects hardly ever work out, and Will Middlebrooks/Yoán Moncada/yada yada yada. Let's not build the pressure up too much on these kids in which a fanbase exists that is already utterly lacking in patience (and I don't blame them to a degree after the last few years - but Jesus!)

The thing is, I get the frustration. I definitely think there's legit reasons to question a few things - our hitting with RISP has been utterly abysmal for what feels like two years, we're striking out a lot, and we seem to have gone quite a way away from the team that grinds out bats and wears out the SP - now whether these are simply player or coach issues is hard to say (and too reductive), but it's fair to question this stuff. But the absolute assurance some people post things with as if known fact is hard to stomach, especially when they're just pulling it from their ass. It's mid April. People are expecting perfection already. The game threads are a tough read. To say the least. I think taking a few days off watching the team would do a lot of people some good.

I second this proposal. Until I find out I'm one of the people getting the call and being sent down, and thus forced to slap Tim Anderson across the face.

How do you know they are way too comfortable with weak performances? Don't make the mistake of watching a highly edited and stylistic documentary series and thinking you know them intimately. You can trust me on this, I've just made one of these series (my 3rd), and things get left on the cutting floor that would utterly change your mind on what so you're so sure of now. People have really got their heads up their arses over this (admittedly) not amazing start. People need to chill out. Half the players should be demoted or traded and all the staff should be sacked off if we took a consensus of Sox fans this past week. Lunacy.

There are clearly a few issues that are concerning the longer they carry on (if they do) but I swear more and more fans somehow completely forget what baseball can be like at the start of every ST and the panic is setting in earlier and earlier. Trading Duran (for who? for what?) to fit in two untested kids is right up there.

Yes, I broke my own golden rule of small samples mean nothing after that feelgood day. That said, I'm not worried about this team at all. They're going to be fine.

Yes, the money will continue to go up for sure. Which makes the contracts we've dished out all the better recently.

Indeed. Feels very positive at the major and minor levels right now.

Makes me think more and more that it was likely the adjustment to being DH and all the fuss around him in the summer, rather than it being a shoulder issue.