cp176
-
Posts
10,750 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Boston Red Sox Videos
2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking
Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits
Guides & Resources
2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker
News
2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by cp176
-
5 years is fine.
-
Is Benintendi as bad as the metrics depict him to be? Watching him play, it is hard for me to buy the fact that he is not an average if not better ss. Granted there are others who really are substantially better but is he really as bad as some scream on here that he is? I don't think so. I do still think that any metric you can find that can help you with making any kind of decision can and should be used but blanket statements made on what certain stats seem to indicate is ridiculous. Many of us, like you and I, realize the importance of using what is available to help in the decision process but it won't change anyone's perspective of us or what we believe if we do not buy into the concept that advanced metrics is really the only way to go ultimately. We are old fashioned and grossly behind the times. Lastly, JBJ in centerfield gives us an edge over almost every team in mlb. He ain't bad!
-
I got it and the point makes sense. I don't think that signing Martinez to a reasonably lengthed contract is going to be any kind of an issue. I will say that I am not as enamored with the members of this current team as some here are. There are very few on this current roster that I care enough about to offer them gobs of $ to reup. A couple, yes, but not many. I also truly believe that someday JH is going to sell this team and when he does, the profit he makes will make any budget that we have now or have going forward look paltry.
-
What a finish - a simple little half-court trap on the sideline. Should absolutely never work right? Tell that to big ben when he throws the last pass of the game into the absolute middle of the field. It is about the mental!!!
-
yankidyy do!
-
We have a young star? Just kidding sort of. I like Betts, Benintendi, and Devers as much as the next guy but it is possible that we think that they are better than they actually are.
-
They can't , they just can't stop worrying about the $. It is who they are. I'm with you though. I know little and could care less about the luxury tax.
-
I was aware of it. The problem I see for many of us really though is that we tend to seriously overrate prospects that show any potential at all. Most of them just aren't that GD good when compared to what other teams have.
-
Stanton: I KNEW there was a reason I didn't like Jeter!
cp176 replied to Carter's topic in Boston Red Sox Talk
They should get many good years from a 28 year old. How good? Who knows. It really is a guessing game with most of these guys. I really don't see him as being the best hitter in baseball. A powerful hitter for sure but also has a little injury track record. I remember the euphoria surrounding the Hanley signing. I was never quite so sure of that signing. His most productive years looked to be behind him and he had had to deal with various injuries as well. Only time will tell what becomes of Stanton. I'm really not big time disappointed that we did not sign him. We still need that bat though! -
Very likely true.
-
Interesting points made.
-
I just find it very encouraging that 6 of our top ten prospects are pitchers. Either our prospects just aren't very good or someone has seen the importance of developing our own pitchers these days.
-
I would think that he could and we know that there are teams out there who want him.
-
I don't know the names of the guys out there who could be targeted but I cannot help but think that JBJ with a few others kicked in, that we should be able to come away with someone decent. With that being said, i still don't really want to see JBJ go anywhere and there is still a good chance that he will stay put.
-
Stanton: I KNEW there was a reason I didn't like Jeter!
cp176 replied to Carter's topic in Boston Red Sox Talk
Which is a legitimate risk when you have a fairly young guy who has missed as much game time as he has. -
I agree for sure. i love JBJ and what he has done for Boston but signing Martinez and picking up a solid starter works for me. We have all been educated as to the fact that it is all about business. I also don't think that Martinez sucks in the outfield quite as much as some people think he does. We give up something but we gain a lot as well.
-
I think that that is a good possibility.
-
dastardly deliberate Dave - ever the optimist here. Martinez comes to Boston and JBJ is packaged for a good arm. That is what I have been saying for a long time now. Not going to change until I see Martinez sign with someone else.
-
I could be up for a little Nunez signing myself right about now.
-
Crowd needs to relax - i don't think that anybody is contemplating moving a gold glove right fielder back to second base. I do find it odd to hear how many people here are in favor of moving Devers and Bogaerts, positionally in addition to thinking that having JD Martinez in our outfield is just as unreasonable as maybe Hanley being able to play first. Add to that the number of people who think that it is an easy transition for lifelong middle infielders to move to corner infield positions and continue to consistently make plays, and I just have to chuckle. For the record, i was not advocating a move to second for Betts but he was a very good second baseman.
-
Stanton: I KNEW there was a reason I didn't like Jeter!
cp176 replied to Carter's topic in Boston Red Sox Talk
My point exactly. he may appear as the face of the org. but really I doubt seriously his voice is as powerful as some think it is. -
I suppose that you could say just about the same thing about Stanton if you go back and look at the total number of games played since he broke in. Now I would not like to see a trade of JBJ. I like our outfield as is but with respect to the durability of free agents that get signed, I guess that some of it is just a chance you take. I would also add that as much as I like Betts in the outfield, I always felt that he would wind up back at second base for the Sox. He was pretty good thee as well.
-
Hope that this is true. It almost sounds like it might be a little too good to be true. I hope that Dombrowski and Borass have that type of relationship. I'd be happily surprised.
-
I for sure didn't drink the good time - they all hit way below their averages - it is so unusual - and the long ball is grossly overrated kool aid, but we better all sure as hell hope that we get more out of Hanley and Mookie for sure. It would be nice to see X getting a little back and to see some progression from Benintendi. If we don't - if last year is who these guys are - we are just spinning tires.
-
I think that you are right on here. I doubt very much that DD is just twiddling thumbs. Tough negotiations would be my guess.