Another point you may want to consider on the asterisk thing: in Manfred's report on the Red Sox 2018 sign stealing, it explicitly says that it did not occur in the postseason.
I read the comments section in the Globe story about JBJ leaving the team. It was a mixed reaction to say the least. There were a lot of people calling him a lousy hitter and an overrated player.
I don't really get how you're framing this. Just that you're leaving out that keeping Betts for 2019 would also mean getting virtually nothing for him.
I think you have to give Friedman his due. I believe that when he made this trade he figured he had a shot at signing Mookie to an extension, and that was an integral part of why he did it.
Every team has issues of some sort unless they're the 1998 Yankees or one of the other juggernauts.
The pertinent question with DD's Tigers is whether it was the bullpen that prevented them from winning titles between 2011 and 2014.
Anyone who subscribes to the playoffs are a crapshoot theory to any degree would have to answer no.
John Henry knows all this. He didn't get where he is by being a dummy.
The Red Sox have said the reason they hired Bloom was to try to have more consistent good results. Henry no doubt got tired of the roller coaster ride that started in 2011. And I believe he thought a large part of the problem was trying to fix everything with big splashy signings.
We need to give Bloom a chance.
When it's 4 years in a row, I think it's a fair argument, yes.
But if we want to turn this into a playoffs/crapshoot discussion, that's kind of a different thing.
The bullpen was not a strength. But the first place finishes suggest that was not a big issue.
And when trying to show it was what cost them titles, using that one pitch by Benoit is fun, but not really fact-based.