I think everyone would agree that pitching 6 innings and allowing 2 runs would be a good performance by a starter.
To get a win in that situation, you need:
a) Your hitters to score at least 3 runs in the 6 innings.
Your relievers not to blow the lead.
Obviously neither one is a slam dunk.
One more time - Aaron Nola was 32-31 in his last 3 seasons. That's an average record of 10.7-10.3.
Dombrowski gave him a contract for 7 years and 172 million.
And as far as I know, you think Dombrowski is a good CBO.
You really have no counterargument to this. Because there isn't one.
It's not just the wins, it's the W-L spread and % that Old Schoolers still love.
I mean, Mike Wacha's 25-6 record over the last 2 years is a fun number, but it doesn't mean he's the guy you want instead of Nola or Montgomery...
I really and truly believe you can do things that are good for both baseball and PR. For example, the Sox extending Mookie Betts would have been wicked good PR...
If an Old Schooler still likes to cite ERA, I get that. But I don't get still thinking W-L record is a big deal. If W-L record really matters to you, you must think it's absolutely insane how much more money Nola got than Wacha did.
OK, you and Denny are the co-chairs of the "W-L record still really matters" committee here.
Aaron Nola is 32-31 over the last 3 seasons. DD must have been clean out of his mind paying him 172 million!
An official offer is an official signed-off legal document much like an offer to buy a house, right? It's binding, and if the other side signs too, it's a deal, pending the inspection etc.