Fred, you have a tendency to not read other people's posts very carefully and also, for your own convenience, you tend to lump people together as if they have identical views even if they don't.
So let me clarify something. My argument is not with Youkilis being traded. I have said that he should be traded to make way for WMB. My argument with Nick was that I don't think Cherington is an 'incompetent fool' who made a 'huge blunder' for not trading Youkilis this past offseason (rather than before the July/12 trade deadline). I also don't accept that Youkilis is a clubhouse cancer because some writers say he is. That's about it.