The media doesn't have much credibility about this meeting. Obviously, their "source" is an enemy of Valentine and the details may have been exagerrated. Once the media sees blood, they attack like sharks, and the Red Sox are bloody. It may be the front office is the source, since their policy all year has been, it appears, to deliberately undermine Valentine.
True, Valentine has a big mouth and has been too honest with the media about some of his players. But the public "defense" of Valentine, with Cherington, Lucchino and Henry as a "team", was pretty sickening, and tells you a lot about the Red Sox. Valentine is stupid not to resign immediately. Lucchino dealt him a bad hand. He should walk away from the manure pile.