The Peter Principle is alive and well in the Red Sox organization.
The media would have you believe Cherington is at the same level Epstein was. Not true.
Epstein was a VP of player personnel, one step up from GM. He was promoted after his gorilla suit tantrum. Lucchino moved over to VP of marketing, etc. Cherington doesn't have the same authority as Theo, and shouldn't--as a first year GM. But the media ignores these differences. He never should have led the managerial search as a newly appointed GM--not with his lack of experience.
The mistake Henry made was not replacing Epstein by an experienced guy at the same VP level. Somebody from the outside with clout, free of all the infighting. Somebody, as I've said, like John Hart. But they screwed it up. The outsider they brought in was the Manager-- a lower level without any clout. What happened is predictable.
How a guy like Henry, who has made a zillion dollars in hedge funds, can screw up a ball team with the wrong moves, is beyond me. And Lucchino was no help, either. These guys completely swung and missed.