Strider pitched more innings, had a higher k/9, lower bb/9, 20 WINS!, better FIP. Aside from ERA, everything about Strider's season was better AND he played on a team that was competitive and got to the playoffs. I would have went Strider > Gallen > Snell.
Also, there is a much longer answer about ownership giving Bloom leeway for not entirely handling the '22 deadline well. Bloom then has a pretty terrible offseason (in part due to him having to reset the CBT), which includes a very ugly performance at the Winter Weekend where the crowd lustfully boos him. He turtles during the '23 deadline and the team completely falls apart with lots of conversation around the team feeling like they were just left out to dry and not given help from the FO.
Bloom made several missteps, but the biggest one was the '22 deadline and not trading JD which would have put the team under the CBT (better comp picks, better '23 offseason).
I think they are getting close to stumbling into a roaring fire. They generated a lot of goodwill, but really have a had some bad looks the past few years. I think Sox fans still want their owners to show them that they care as much as the fans do.
They wanted to see if he could pull '23 off. He may have kept his job if he had re-signed Wacha and went for another cheapo like Miley, instead of Kluber.
'23 FAs:
Heyward 720k, 2.2 fWAR
G Sanchez 1M, 1.7 fWAR
W Smith 1.4M, 1.1 fWAR
A Chapman 3.5M, 1.8 fWAR
Wacha 6.5M, 2.6 fWAR
Duvall 7M, 1.9 fWAR
You can find good players without having to overpay. It just becomes more of a crapshoot.
The signing doesn't have to be sexy to work. About 50% of all FA signings look ugly at the end of the next season. Crag just has to find the guys that will be effective. There will be a few below market FA's that succeed this year. Will they find them? Is it important enough to Crag to sell it to the fans? Maybe as an ex-ballplayer he doesn't really care about the PR side? Take a hit now, but build a good team.
I think we'd all be happy with this offseason if they are playing meaningful games in September with Crag signings that are working out and a retooled pitching program that is finally showing signs of life.
I don't have a crystal ball, but it's more likely they go the Paxton/Giolito/Montas grab bag route. "We're going to be competitive. The goal is the playoffs. Yada... Yada... Nada."