Was Pavano really that sought after? He had 1 good season out of 7 before coming to the Yankees. But I guess your FO knew more than everybody else...
You know something? You're right. They didn't give up much to get Brown. What's 15.5 million a year?
They were all bad moves, any way you slice it. Pavano, Igawa, Brown, and Wright were bad signings even without retrospect. They got a little unlucky with Johnson and Contreras. Some guys can't pitch in New York, though. Letting Santana go was embarrassing.