I was going to go with another guy for my 5th starter (I'll name him once someone else picks him), but his health is a concern. His last start was awful, and for whatever reason he hasn't been the same the last 2 seasons.
I'm aware Blackburn will probably be panned by some of you because of his low K/9, but I like him. Obviously pitches to contact. Somehow, though, he gets the job done. He's 27, has good mechanics, and makes pitches when he has to. I think he'll be able to consistently give me around 200 innings a year, an ERA of 4.00 or under 4.00, and a WHIP around 1.3. And if that's the case, what more could you want from a 5th starter?