How many 3B make All Star game? 2? Even with Shaw's numbers, he is still at best the 3rd best 3B in his own division, behind Donaldson and Machado. Not a knock on Shaw at all, those two are probably two best at the position in the MLB and are both MVP candidates, but Shaw would need a ridiculous season/injury to beat both those guys out.
Even if he isn't Machado or Donaldson, he is a hell of a player and is performing better both offensively and defensively then anyone could've hoped. Lets hope he keeps it up.