He can occasionally be right, just like Colin Cowherd who I also despise. However, I feel like more times than not they’re saying something absolutely ridiculous for clicks and half the stuff they argue they don’t actually believe in or if they do believe in it, they shouldn’t be allowed to talk about sports for a living.
Stephen A Smith has multiple times defended athletes who hit women and even said and implied women are to blame sometimes when it happens, specifically defending Ray Rice. Colin Cowherd said John Wall wouldn’t be a good role model or leader because he didn’t have a dad in his life. John Wall’s dad died from cancer when he was young and John Wall was one of the best players in the league and even better off the field. He has won multiple awards for his community service is heavily involved with young kids battling cancer after both his parents died from it.
And when it comes to baseball, both have criticized non American players unfairly and have been fired/suspended for it, but still continue to get jobs and a platform. Maddie already mentioned SAS’s comments about Ohtani and non English speaking players but Cowherds comments about Dominican players was even worse.