I don't anticipate us getting Lidge. His name has been off the market so to speak for about a month now. If we trade I think we go for Cordero, even tho we will most likely have to give up more. I watched Cordero pitch in DC in 2005, he has great stuff and for a young guy his confidence level is right where you want it. He is reliable, and for his age has alot of experience closing games. His number might inflate a little coming to the AL East, but since hes so young there still time for him to adjust and bring them back down.
If not Cordero or Lidge, the theres Gonzalez, but NYY are offering Proctor and Melky( which is absurd). If NYY is going to give that much up, i'd rather not see us top that deal, again if we had to give up that much Id rather it be Cordero.
Then we have internal option, Hansen,Hansack both are big ?'s, but so was Paps heading into the season.
My darkhorse pick( this is just me taking a guess for fun) Would be Bard. Yes I know hes a starter and hasn't been passed AA, but it be fun to watch him come in for one inning and let it rip at 100MPH, he hits 95-98 regulary during starts. You can get away with a little more when you hit 100MPH and only pitching one inning wouldnt be to stressful on his arm. Trust me I don't really expect to see this, I just felt like putting it out there:D