Yes I agree Melky has a good eye, good plate dicpline, but thats really it, no power, no great glove skills, regular arm, avg. speed. He's mainly a contact hitter, which isn't bad he'll get on base at a good clip with the protection he has, but put him outside of that protection he's nothing really great just avg.
I just don't understand why people are so hi on him, hes decent but some talk about him as a big time up and comer, but if he leaves NY, you will see what he really is.