Ok guys heres my 2 cents worth...
As bad is it may sound, Schilling is an un proven commodity as of right now. His 2nd half last yr was horrible, we don't know for sure whether or not he can go a whole season or not. And believe me I'm not anti-Schilling, but the way the Sox office is handling this is the correct way. It is a bad buisness decision to allocate 13M of the 08 payroll for a player you are not sure is worth it in 07. You guys that think he should get a contract extension just because of what he did in 04 need to take a step back, take a breath and think about it again. Schilling was great that yr don't get me wrong, but Pedro,Lowe,OC,Millar,Roberts,Foulke,Muellher,Damon, they all had a part in it too but were not screaming at the FO for letting them go(except for Damon, but in all honesty it wast the 3rd and 4th yrs of the contract they where worried about, so we will come back to that one maybe next yr)
Pedro, people didn´t want to see him go but look at him now, won´t pitch until late 07. We would still have him under contract for 2 more years if we had given in just because of what he did in 04, and be stuck with no Pedro and the money on his contract.
Lowe, his contract looks good now but in 04 it was a bit hi for a #3-#4 pitcher.
OC, good SS but nothing wonderful, but did handle the pressure in Boston not bad.
Millar, whoever said that all the replacements we found for these guys is wrong, Millar good 04 was enough to bring him back for 05(because he was also pretty cheap too) but he stunk to hi hell in 05 and Youk was atleast a notch better then compared to him.
Muellher, can´t play anymore
Damon, see above...
Theres a saying( cant remeber exact phrasing) If GM´s listened or did there jobs like fans, they would soon be sitting next to them in the stands.... or along those lines, but in all honesty, this is why none of us are GM´s. We love the nastalga of things, we want to see our hero Schilling finish his career with the Sox, and Clemens too for that matter and all of the other players we have loved so much. But if we did that wed be a 3rd place team, with a bunch of over payed old players. And that is the plain truth of the matter. Thats why people like Theo and company are GM,FO people, they can seperate themselves from the fan part of the game. There Job is to put a winning team on the field, if they don´t the have to answer to the owners, the fans ect. They cant have that sentiment,or atleast show it when it comes to these decisions.
Guys if schilling comes out and has a great 07 then the team will most likely give him the extension. He said he would play for 13M and he wasn´t looking for a raise, so if he files for FA and them leaves the team for more money or guranteed yrs then thats on him.
We also have to consider that hes been saying his last season is 07, and in doing that, the FO might have the 13M he wants ear marked for other things. Because you know its not just this season the FO thinks about, its also the future wellfare of the club too. I for one would rather see them put the 13M towards a hitter next off season. If schilling really is declining then it wont be hard for a rookie pitcher to put up comparable numbers for a fraction of the price.