Here is something that I am starting to believe happened....and that my tiny little brain believes, lol. Santana going to the Mets....was agreed upon by the Yankees and Red Sox.
Wait a second before you dismiss this off-hand. Think about this.
Theo and Cashman are reputed to be friends and get along. They just hung out together for some official function just before the Santana deal.
Is it inconceivable that the following happened?
Cash: Theo, I got a deal for you. I don't want to give up my farm system for this guy. Do you?
Theo: Not really. I think my kids are better than yours.
Cash: Funny, I was thinking the same about mine. So here's my deal. Let's both pass, and let him go to the Mets. My feeling is that Santana is going to blow his arm out sometime during the extension he wants, and then I'm screwed. However, with Hank breathing down my neck, I won't have a job if you get him.
Theo: I'm still listening Cash...but what if they drop their demands?
Cash: They will. They'll probably come to me first. I'll decline, then you do the same. Let the Mets tie up their money for years, and kill their payroll. After all, three years from now, we'd both be better if we didn't make this deal.
Theo: Sounds good to me. You're gonna get killed in the press.
Cash: Not if I'm holding the 2008 World Series trophy.
Theo: What if I don't let you? Ok...agreed. Let's see who can build a team better from the ground up.
Cash: Good..now what?
Theo: Hmm...wanna hit up 49th street and find us some hookers?
Cash: Only if their Asian.
Theo: That's what I'm talking about...let's go, I'll drive.
I really believe this coulda happened.