First of all...even I, the anti-Cashman, have to admit it was a good deal. However, let's not put the 2009 World Series trophy in the new Yankee Stadium yet.
Swisher is a below average 1B and outfielder overall. He does not hit for average, and his power is below average for a corner OF or 1B, at least compared to what we are used to in New York.
He does bring somethings to the table. He can play all 3 OF positions, average in the corners and below average in center. He is an average to above-average defensive 1B. In replacing Giambi at 1B, he gives you a better glove and a weaker bat. However, as a switch-hitter who is basically equal from both sides of the plate, he balances the lineup a bit.
His biggest contribution is that he led the league in pitches seen per AB at 4.51 P/PA among qualified hitters. He also had the lowest BA in all of baseball for players who qualified for the batting title.
If Swisher is a starter come opening day, Cashman has done a poor job at filling the OF or 1B. However, as a player on the bench, one who can rotate among all 3 OF positions and 1B, he is a very valuable sub and is great insurance against injury. That's it guys. A good move, but a minor one.
Let's remember too...Marquez is one of the players the Twins wanted for Santana. Just throwing that in there.
Now...for additional commentary on the commentary of my fellow Yankee fan.
Good point. Agreed. However, his upside is not that great either. They bought low, but it's still not a high-impact move.
He's a switch-hitter, and Comisky is hitter-friendly. Considering the talented pitching staffs in the AL East, a decline is just as likely as an improvement.
Agreed. Although his defense in CF is below average, expect to see Gardner cover CF more. This all but ends Melky's tenure in New York. Look for the Yankees to deal Melky...a good fit may be to the Padres. Towers and Cashman have a good history, and Melky would go a long way in CF in the spacious San Diego Park. Could this move have been made with the idea of packaging Melky with a super-prospect or two for Peavy?
Not necessarily my friend. He may have peaked early, it happens a lot. Keep in mind that just because a player joins your team, he won't necessarily get better...or worse. An OPS between .750 and .825 is more likely.
He is overpaid as a sub, and not talented enough to be a regular. However, money is not the concern it would be for other teams.
Agreed. It gives us depth on our roster where we were weak, the bench, but it is not a game-changer type of move.
I'm not as excited as you or 26 about this move, but our team is better than it was yesterday.