Look...I am not against buiding from within. In fact, I'm all for it. I'm also for improving the team in free agency & trades. Who isn't?
My problem is with the person in charge. I haven't really seen anything I like.
You guys are talking like building from within is a novel concept that he came up with. The Red Sox develop better talent. So do the Cubs. So do the Dodgers. So do the Mets. In fact...every large market team develops better talent than the Yankees. Why? Man in charge. The thing is, the two men before him, Stick and Watson, did the job better than him by a long shot. It's not even close. Stick took a terrible team and build a championship roster. Watson kept it going. Cashman ran it into the ground. Last I saw...the both worked for the same ownership group.
I think he's one of the worst GMs in the game. If it wasn't for the ludicrous amount of money he has at his disposal, he would fail miserably.
Now..that being said...a GMs job is a "what have you done for me lately" position. So...he still has a chance to salvage his standing. If you remember, he said that if he had left, he wouldn't have "liked what was written" about his tenure.
What would have been written is that he was a failure.
Now...lets look at the issues this team has at this point in time.
He has two starting pitchers under contract, both coming off major injuries.
Wang
Chamberlain
He has a very solid bullpen.
He has a lineup that is highly dependent on one player for most of it's power in Arod.
He needs to replace the production of Giambi and Abreu.
Forget his mistakes in the past, which have cost the Yankees dearly.
He needs to fill three rotation spots, and acquire at least one solid bat to protect Arod in the lineup.
Let's see what he does. My hope? CC, AJ, and Manny/Tex. Leave the fifth spot for Hughes or take a chance on Sheets rather than Andy.
If he gets three of those four, I'll change my tune. If he gets one, he has failed. If he gets none, he should be fired immediately.